Tasty Custom Cakes & Baked Goods: Tasty Pastry Bakery in Tallahassee

Welcome to Tasty Pastry

Tallahassee’s Original Cakery
Celebrating Over 50 Years!

Tasty Pastry Tasty Treats: Overflowing Basket of a Variety of Bread (rolls, sliced, bagels, plaited)

Breads

Tasty Pastry Tasty Treats: Closeup on 2 stacked brownies with nuts and chocolate frosting

Brownies

Tasty Pastry Tasty Treats: 3 unique custom-designed cakes

Cakes

Tasty Pastry Cookies: 8 different types of cookies assorted on a wooden surface

Cookies

Tasty Pastry Tasty Treats: 3 Flavors of Cupcakes topped with icing

Cupcakes

Tasty Pastry Muffins: 5 different types of muffins (includes lemon poppyseed & choc chip) on plate

Muffins

Tasty Pastry Tasty Treats: Extreme closeup on a flaky pastry

Pastries

Tasty Pastry Tasty Treats: Close-up on Flaky Pie Crust with Apple Filling spilling out

Pies