Tasty Pastry can whip up just about any style pie, cheesecake, or individual dessert you desire. We always keep a selection of fresh, seasonal favorites on hand. Call us or email us to request your favorite!
Tasty Pastry pies are filled with joy and happiness inside!
Pies
From a truly American apple pie to a Lemon Meringue, at Tasty Pastry we bake pies of all kinds! There are traditional, fruit-filled pies with a flaky crust, custards like coconut and banana cream, and fancy favorites like French silk. Our seasonal pies include pumpkin, pecan and mincemeat.
Flavors: Apple, Cherry or Blueberry, Pecan, French Silk, Key Lime, Coconut Cream, Chocolate Cream, Banana Cream, Lemon Meringue, Pumpkin (Seasonal), Peanut Butter
Cheesecakes
You don’t have to go far to get real New York-style cheesecake. We make it right here! Try an untopped traditional cake or try one topped with a variety of your favorite toppings. Our favorites include cherry, blueberry, pineapple, etc.. In the mood for chocolate? How about turtle or chocolate chip?
Flavors: New York Style, plain or with fruit topping (cherry, strawberry, blueberry), Chocolate Chip, Turtle (caramel and pecans), and Chocolate Decadence (with poured ganache)
French Pastries and Individual Desserts
For something smaller, but absolutely decadent, try one of our individual desserts like chocolate éclairs, napoleons, cannoli, mini cheesecakes or fresh fruit tarts—the perfect snack or end to a romantic dinner for two.
Cookies
Regular Cookies: Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal, Peanut Butter, Molasses, White Chocolate Macadamia, Old Fashioned Sugar and Chocolate-Chocolate Chip
Gourmet Cookies: Chocolate Chunk, M&M, Chinese Marble, Gingerbread Men (year round), Coconut Macaroons
Other Varieties: Butter Cookies (sprinkle or chocolate chip), Wedding Cookies, and Center Filled
Brownies and Bars
Brownie Flavors: Fudge Brownies with or without nuts, Cream Cheese Brownies, Rocky Road Brownies, and Home-style (no icing or nuts)
Bar Flavors: Magic Bars, Date Bars, Pecan Squares, and Lemon Squares
Petit Fours
Our petits fours are very popular for weddings and baby showers. They come standard with white cake, strawberry filling and a white glaze.
Holiday Treats
Contact us for more information about our assorted seasonal products.
Contact Tasty Pastry
1355 Market Street, #A-5
Tallahassee, FL 32312
Business Hours:
Monday - Saturday
6:45 a.m. to 6 p.m.
Contact Us:
850-893-3752
Email: info@tastypastrybakery.com
